top of page

Practice the whole task after stroke

26 minutes ago
2 min read

Many sessions break a goal into parts. Strengthen the hip. Work on ankle movement. Then, near the end of the session, try a few steps. The sequence makes sense on paper, and part work has its place. The question I keep coming back to is simpler: did the patient get better at the thing they came in for?


Graphic titled Practice the whole task, with a wavy line rising from a start dot to an open end circle.

What motor learning tells us


Motor learning is how a person acquires and refines a movement skill through practice. Krakauer and colleagues review the motor learning research behind this idea, including how skills are acquired through practice [1].


What the walking guideline says


The 2020 locomotor clinical practice guideline by Hornby and colleagues covers walking after chronic stroke, incomplete spinal cord injury and brain injury [2]. Its abstract reports strong evidence that clinicians should offer walking training at moderate to high intensities. It also says large amounts of task-specific walking practice may be critical for improving walking, and it notes a limit: it may not apply to people who need substantial physical help to walk.


Read the full text before you cite a recommendation to a colleague, a patient or a family. The strength of the wording and the population it describes both matter.


Where part practice fits


Two panels. The left panel, Part practice, shows a broken path with a square in the middle between a start circle and a goal triangle. The right panel, Whole task practice, shows one continuous curve from the start circle to the goal.

Some parts need work first. A patient who cannot yet bear weight on one leg may not be ready for stepping practice. Part practice can help build the abilities a whole task needs, so use it on purpose. This is clinical reasoning, not a finding from the sources above.


Then check the transfer. After the exercise, does the walking, reaching or dressing change? If it does not, either the part is not the limit, or the whole task needs practice too.


Fade the feedback as the patient improves


Graphic titled Fade the feedback: a row of dots, dense on the left and labeled Early: frequent feedback, becoming sparse on the right and labeled Later: less feedback, along an arrow.

Feedback tells a learner what to change. The Hornby guideline's discussion notes that walking training may matter most at higher intensities or with augmented feedback [2]. The sources checked for this post do not give a schedule for reducing feedback, so the steps below are clinical judgment to test in your own sessions.


Early in a new task, give feedback often and keep it specific. As the patient improves, let them judge their own movement first. Then give feedback after a few attempts instead of after every one.


Try it in your next session


Pick one walking, reaching or transfer goal from your patient's plan. Write down the whole task, then the parts you would use to reach it. Practice the whole task in the session at a level the patient can manage. Note the feedback you gave and when you reduced it. Check next session whether the skill held.


Go deeper


The Intervention Mastery course covers motor learning principles, task-specific training and constraint-induced movement therapy. It is self-paced, with 3 months of access, no prerequisites and a one-time price of $200.


See the full course lineup on the courses page, or go straight to Intervention Mastery.


References


  1. Krakauer JW, Hadjiosif AM, Xu J, Wong AL, Haith AM. Motor learning. Compr Physiol. 2019;9(2):613-663. doi:10.1002/cphy.c170043.

  2. Hornby TG, Reisman DS, Ward IG, et al. Clinical Practice Guideline to Improve Locomotor Function Following Chronic Stroke, Incomplete Spinal Cord Injury, and Brain Injury. J Neurol Phys Ther. 2020;44(1):49-100. doi:10.1097/NPT.0000000000000303.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page